Get the opportunity to grow your influence by giving your products or services prime exposure with Performance Magazine.

If you are interested in advertising with Performance Magazine, leave your address below.

    Advertise with us

    Posts Tagged ‘workplace culture’

    The Manager Effect: How Leadership Can Make or Break Team Performance

    FacebooktwitterlinkedinFacebooktwitterlinkedin

    The Manager Effect_ How Leadership Can Make or Break Team Performance banner

    A certain type of employee seems to appear in every company. These are the people who never seem to meet deadlines, who always have to be pushed to get their work done, who make the same mistakes over and over again, who don’t seem to do much on their own, and who never seem to try very hard.

    At some point, it seems, every manager has decided, “Well, this employee just isn’t performing,” and sometimes, they may well be right. This begs the question, though: How much of this poor performance was actually caused by the manager?

    This has the potential to be a wildly uncomfortable question, since managers are, by definition, responsible for judging performance. They set standards, determine who is doing the best and worst jobs, decide who gets promoted and who gets fired. They evaluate and judge. They decide what’s acceptable and what isn’t.

    Yet here’s the thing: management comes before performance.

    Managers decide what’s important, what gets done and what doesn’t, what gets approved and what gets dismissed, what gets rewarded and what gets punished. Managers decide how much autonomy employees have, how much freedom they have, how much leeway is allowed, how quickly problems are solved, and how much employees understand what they’re supposed to be doing.

    In short, managers don’t just evaluate performance; they have tremendous influence over it. They may be standing in the control room, but they’re also often the ones pushing all the buttons.

    The Employee & Manager Slices of the Problem Pie

    • A 2024 NBER study sought to identify the causal effect of managers on their teams’ performance. 

    The paper’s authors experimented with repeated reallocations of managers, controlling for differences in the skill sets of the teams. The purpose of the experiment was to quantify the effect of a simple managerial change, and the results were astounding.

    The study found that good managers improved their teams’ performance by approximately double the number of “good workers” would have. The paper uses the phrase “good manager” to denote someone who consistently drove better-than-expected results from their team. 

    N.B.: The cited results do not mean managers are twice as productive as employees. Far from it – both the phrasing and the findings suggest the opposite.

    The findings suggest that if you hire a good manager, you cannot simply lay off half your staff in favour of the manager and expect double the performance. Neither do they suggest that employees are fungible or that an outstanding manager would be able to extract twice the performance from any arbitrary set of subordinates.

    What the study does suggest is that the people managing your team can affect your team’s performance by a surprisingly wide margin. It suggests that both your employees and your managers matter, and that the combination of the two matters even more.

    • Another NBER study of transfers between stores in two large retail chains found that, given the consistency of management practices across the businesses, studying how individual managers affected the performance of their new teams gave a less distorted view of the contribution to productivity that a manager can reasonably be expected to provide.

    Both these studies suggest not that employees are unimportant, but that “the team is underperforming” is a dangerously incomplete diagnosis. Your team may be underperforming because your employees lack the experience, skill, or commitment to do the job well. It may be that your employees are entirely appropriate for the task, but they are, in fact, being managed poorly – either at the level of individual contributors or individual executives. It may also be that your employees are being managed by an ineffective manager, an ineffective system, or a combination of the two.

    Consider the following scenario: 

    1. Your manager changed your team’s priorities on Monday. 
    2. You spent all of Tuesday prioritizing the newly prioritized project. 
    3. On Wednesday, an emergency cropped up, and you had to change priorities again. 
    4. On Thursday, your manager asked you why the first project wasn’t getting done. 
    5. On Friday, you found out the delivery date for the first project had slipped because of something that happened in another department. 

    When you go into your performance review, your manager tells you that you need to be more organized, take more ownership, and all the usuals. Maybe you do need to be more organized, but have you considered that it may not be your responsibility to rearrange your entire workload when priorities change?

    This is why management should not be considered an optional part of the performance system – because it is an integral part of the performance system. It has to be. Research on role ambiguity shows that when there is insufficient clarity about what’s expected of you, your performance tends to suffer. 

    This does not mean that every underperforming employee is necessarily being managed badly. However, it does mean that we can no longer think of clarity of expectations as an employee competency. That kind of clarity is frequently the responsibility of managers, which, again, puts it squarely in the realm of managerial responsibility. Using this framework to understand performance issues can help you recognize some “bad” behaviours as the result of years of poor management.

    • An employee who is afraid to make decisions may have learned that decisions are rarely wrong. 
    • An employee who asks permission constantly may have learned that acting without permission makes them look foolish. 
    • An employee who is disengaged and cynical may have learned that no matter how hard they try, nothing changes. 
    • An employee who misses priorities may have been given too many changing priorities. 
    • An employee who always works right up to a deadline may have learned that nothing gets done before one. 
    • An employee who can’t do anything without their manager may, in fact, have been taught that by their manager.

    This brings us to one of the most damaging management practices: managerial interference.

    When managers interfere with the day-to-day responsibilities of their direct reports, they train those direct reports to deal with everything at a level two steps below their actual level of responsibility. It doesn’t matter whether they are “helping,” “teaching,” “managing,” or “holding accountable.” Interference creates inconsistency, confusion, and the impression that the manager can’t handle anything without stepping in. Employees managed this way may always present problems at the executive level. 

    • They may be unable to own problems or solutions. 
    • They may always need their manager’s help or approval. 
    • They may fear making mistakes without knowing their manager’s input. 
    • They may have become unreasonably rigid in their approach to their responsibilities.

    Micromanagement Can Manufacture the Dependence It Complains About

    Micromanagement is typically defined as a practice that is detrimental to employees because it limits their freedom of action. This is partially true, but it is also a consequence of a much larger effect. Micromanagement can actually cause behavioural changes in people.

    🔄 For example, suppose that you have hired a competent person to do a competent job. They make a decision you wouldn’t have made. You tell them they’re wrong. The next time they’re faced with a similar decision, they ask you what to do. You tell them, they do it, and you correct them again. The next time they’re faced with a similar decision, they ask you what to do. You tell them, they do it, and you correct them again. The next time they’re faced with a similar decision, they ask you what to do. You tell them, they do it, and you correct them again. 🔄

    See where this loop is going? Eventually, they stop making decisions and simply ask you for instructions. You give them more detailed instructions. They ask you for more detailed instructions. You decide that they simply don’t have the initiative to do their job, and you start watching them more carefully.

    🎉 Congratulations! You’ve just created the employee you were originally complaining about! 🎉

    For those scoffing at this example, this is not just theory. A meta-study of 72 studies, 83 samples, and more than 32000 people found that employees who perceived their leaders as acting in an autonomy-supportive manner had more positive work outcomes. This includes positive associations with work performance, engagement and proactive work behaviours, and negative associations with turnover intentions.

    Autonomy-supportive leadership is not being completely uninvolved. It provides freedom in action and decision-making, takes their input into account, and encourages self-initiative without hindering them, which is an extremely important difference.

    Good management is not telling people to do whatever they want, or to do exactly what you would do; rather, it is telling them what you want them to accomplish and letting them do it, while intervening when they cannot accomplish their goals without assistance and helping them when they can. This results in much more competent employees, who are much less reliant on their managers.

    This is especially important because a manager’s job is not to process every single decision that their employees make. If you have to answer every question they have, you’re not managing effectively, and you’ll likely end up with a queue of people waiting to hear from you, rather than competent employees who can handle most things on their own.

    The irony is that managers often fall into this trap precisely because they want to be effective. They feel like they are doing their job by answering every question, but they are actually defeating their purpose.

    Managers are accountable for their team’s performance, so it can be tempting to take responsibility for everything they do, but it is far more effective to let them handle things on their own and intervene only when absolutely necessary.

    This is the difference between a manager who is simply a bottleneck for decision-making, and a manager who actually manages. 

    This is also where the myth of the manager as a performance evaluator falls apart: a manager does not simply determine whether someone can perform; they determine how much opportunity they have to perform.

    That is not to say that a manager is not accountable for performance; it means that they have much less opportunity to affect performance, and much more opportunity to create poor performance by failing to provide the resources, freedom, and feedback necessary to actually perform.

    If someone is consistently underperforming, even when given the resources, freedom, opportunities, and feedback they need, then they are likely to be a poor performer, but if they are not, then they may not be the problem, and it may be the system that is failing them.

    Right now, ten thousand manager voices cried out in agony, objecting virulently because they are often expected to be the ones who determine whether or not someone can perform, and therefore they feel like they need to control everything in order to make that determination.

    The Meaning of Management

    A manager should not try to determine whether someone can perform; they should create an environment in which they can perform, then evaluate whether they are performing, rather than trying to determine whether they can perform.

    This is also the point where many managers will start to see the flaws in their own management practices. The manager who is constantly changing priorities, rewarding the wrong people, avoiding difficult conversations, and putting out fires is not doing so out of malice or incompetence, but rather out of a desire to manage effectively.

    They are trying to create an environment in which their employees can perform, but they are failing to do so; as a result, they constantly have to intervene to prevent employees from failing. Such a method is not an effective way to manage, and it is a sign that the manager is not administering matters effectively.

    It is important to remember that management is a process, and that there are many different ways to achieve its goals. Some managers are better at it than others, and some managers are simply better at certain aspects of it than others.

    However, there are some fundamental principles that all managers should follow, and one of them is providing their employees with the freedom of action and decision-making, taking their input into account, and encouraging self-initiative, while not hindering them.

    The Behaviours You Reward Become the Behaviours You Get

    One of the easiest ways for a manager to destroy performance is to reward the wrong thing, and this is rarely because they are evil. They are usually just rewarding the most obvious things.

    • Someone stayed up late to finish a project – that’s dedication. 10 points for Gryffindor! 
    • Someone dropped everything at 7 pm to help out with an urgent customer problem – that’s heroism. 20 points for Gryffindor!
    • Someone responds to my Slack messages within 30 seconds – they are committed. 30 points for Gryffindor!
    • Someone worked over the weekend to meet a deadline – let’s give them a round of applause. 40 points for Gryffindor!

    Meanwhile, someone quietly fixed the processes that would have stopped the weekend crisis from happening in the first place, but they have gone unnoticed. No points for Ravenclaw!

    Alas, that is how companies end up rewarding people for making fires rather than putting them out. 

    One of the most interesting things about organizational performance is that the market value of various workplace behaviours often bears little relation to what the company says it values. 

    A company can say that it values planning, quality and sustainable performance, but if the people being promoted are the ones who work the longest hours and save the day at the last minute, the rest of the company will quickly learn that last-minute heroics are the most important thing. They are not dim in any way whatsoever; they simply observe their colleagues’ behaviours and learn from them.

    A manager’s actions are effectively a set of behavioural coaching cues for the whole team. 

    • If you reward people for being available to your team at all times, you can expect availability to become a key performance indicator.
    • If you reward speed of response regardless of errors, you’ll get speed of response.
    • If you reward people for taking all decisions up the chain of command, you’ll get a company that cannot make decisions.
    • If you reward people for preventing problems, you’ll get people who prevent problems.
    • If you reward people for being “a bit of a pain but getting things done”, you’ll get people who get things done but are “a bit of a pain”.

    That is why recognition is such a powerful tool. Beyond making people feel good, it sends market-value signals to the team about what is and isn’t important.

    Studies on management practices have found that goals, monitoring and feedback can have a major impact on productivity. In field experiments on airline captains, management practices such as performance monitoring, feedback, target-setting and prosocial incentives all led to significant improvements in targeted fuel-saving behaviours and, in some cases, increases in overall job satisfaction.

    Now, this does not mean that managers should monitor everything. That would simply proliferate the very thing we want to see less of. What it does mean is that monitoring is part of the feedback loop. What you measure, discuss, and reward affects performance. So does what you allow to continue without correction, and most importantly, what you repeatedly rescue.

    If a manager has a team that misses every deadline and responds to every problem by throwing the manager into the fray to “sort it out”, they should ask themselves what they have taught the team. They may believe they have taught the team to do better, but the team has actually learned that the manager will always rescue them when things go wrong. They learn to avoid responsibility and expect the manager to take over when things get tough. Meanwhile, the manager learns that the best way to deal with recurring problems is to rescue people rather than fix systems.

    They have all been conditioned to act that way, without anyone intending to, and that is one of the fundamental problems with management.

    Managers are powerful role models, and everything they do sends behavioural signals to the team. When it comes to busyness, managers don’t have to tell people to work long hours; they model it. 

    • If they work 12-hour days, people will notice. 
    • They will also notice if someone leaves at 5 pm every day and quietly works from home in the evenings.
    • They will notice if someone is praised for working 80-hour weeks and taking no breaks.
    • They will notice if working from home is seen as a perk and taking holidays is presented as selfish.

    They will all learn different lessons about busyness and productivity, adjusting their actions and becoming incredibly busy without actually doing much useful work.

    The difference between busyness and productivity is often invisible to the people involved. 

    • Preventing problems before they occur rarely seems as important as putting out fires. 
    • Processes and procedures are often seen as less exciting than dramatic actions. 
    • Careful decision-making seems less impressive than “thinking on your feet”. 
    • A team that learns to solve its own problems without constantly escalating them to the manager will make the manager feel less important.

    It can make the manager feel redundant, which is why effective managers often feel their contributions are less valued by executives than they should be. They are busy people, making important decisions, solving problems, and rescuing the company from disasters, but those actions do not have the same impact on the bottom line as preventing those disasters from happening in the first place.

    That is the real value of a good manager: they make the company less reliant on them, which makes the company more successful. It also makes the manager less valued by the people at the top.

    Avoiding Problems Doesn’t Keep the Peace – It Changes the Team

    There is a certain kind of management mistake that feels reasonable in the moment:

    • There is a certain employee who doesn’t perform.
      • You think to yourself, “Well, I’ll give them a little time. Maybe they are just having a rough week. I’ll bring it up at their next review. It’s probably not worth creating a scene over.“

    A year later, everyone except the person in charge understands that the employee isn’t performing, but no one has addressed it because, really…who has the time? 

    This mistake is often called avoidance, but it can also be seen as a type of management decision. You’re deciding that this behavior is acceptable, and the rest of your team sees it. You should care because if they are not performing, it impacts the performance of others. It affects your own performance and your team’s culture.

    A team’s culture is not defined by the individuals that make it up, but by the standards they share. People look around and think about what it means to be a good member of their team. What does it mean to miss a deadline, to be rude to a coworker, to be chronically underperforming, to do consistently incredible work?

    Answers to these questions aren’t written anywhere, but they can be found in managers’ actions. If you tolerate one employee who routinely misses deadlines, conscientious employees will start to ask themselves why they are putting in extra effort. They might not think, “Oh, I’m so glad that [slacker] has more flexibility with their schedule,” but they might think, “Maybe I’m working too hard.” This is an example of a single performance issue affecting others’ performance.

    Such instances are why it’s not that difficult actually to have a good conversation and why such conversations should be actively encouraged. A good manager does not have to enjoy difficult conversations, but they should be willing to have them. You don’t have to shame employees or turn every minor performance issue into a morality play, but you should be willing to address issues clearly and directly. You should hold people to standards, because they hold you to standards.

    The research on manager-employee relationships also points to the importance of strong working relationships. In particular, a huge meta-analysis on Leader-Member Exchange Theory highlights the value of positive, supportive relationships between managers and employees. Trust, empowerment, and motivation all lead to positive behaviours like increased performance and citizenship behaviours.

    This isn’t suggesting that managers should be best friends with their reports, but it does highlight the importance of working relationships. You can’t have trust without mutual respect and the feeling that each party is acting in good faith. That applies to both sides of the relationship. Employees have to trust that their manager will support them, but managers also have to trust that their employee will deliver. Neither side gets to demand loyalty or goodwill from the other. They have to earn it by showing up reliably and doing the right thing.

    That’s why inconsistent standards from one employee to the next are so corrosive. 

    • If you promise flexibility to one person because you like them, but deny the same flexibility to another employee who asked, you create distrust on your team. 
    • If you hold one person to consistently lower standards than everyone else, you’re creating similar distrust. 
    • If you tell people that the priorities are one thing, but you change them when it’s convenient for whoever is asking, you’re creating a toxic workplace. 

    It’s easy to dismiss these issues as unfair, but they shouldn’t be dismissed as unimportant. They effectively erode the trust between manager and employee, and once that trust is gone, you can lose your ability to manage effectively.

    Management has a responsibility to set standards. If you’re not enforcing standards, it becomes much harder to enforce standards later. It’s one reason why management is so much harder than employees think. 

    You aren’t walking into a clean slate each morning. You are always working with an existing culture that you help shape, and that helps shape you. 

    • You can make it easier or harder depending on the decisions you make. 
    • You can make problems more visible or more hidden. 
    • You can make employees self-thinking or dependent on you. 
    • You can make excellent performance commonplace, or you can make extraordinary acts the norm. 

    Then, after all is done, when you get caught in the middle of it all, you can think, “Why is my team underperforming?“

    Who knows, maybe you’re right, but maybe you’re not. They might be underperforming, but it might stem from a source or reason where they are giving you honest feedback on your management system.

    So, if you’re thinking about firing them, consider whether firing them would actually solve the problem.

    Final Thoughts

    Sometimes the issue really is the person. Some people are just slovenly, consistently underperforming, and then failing to meet expectations despite your help, guidance, opportunity, and clear communication. 

    Managers aren’t superheroes, and your employees are adults. However, managers bear responsibility for the conditions in which their people work.

    Before moving on to judgment, consider asking yourself a few tough questions:

      • Were expectations clear? 
      • Did your reports have the information, authority, and resources they needed to fulfill the requirements of the position? 
      • Did you address issues before they became problems? 
      • Did you allow failures to dominate conversations, or withhold feedback and opportunities for advancement? 
      • Did you fail to delegate, and take over tasks that were rightfully the responsibility of your people?
    • Would this person be a different performer under a different manager?

    This is not an indictment, but an assessment, since research on managerial impact shows a clear conclusion: managers are often powerful predictors of the performance of the people they lead. 

    So when we find ourselves thinking about firing one of our reports, it’s worth remembering that we may not have maximized the conditions for their success to begin with. 

    This is not to suggest that we can turn poor performers into strong ones by simply changing their managers or through sheer willpower. Nor is anyone arguing that the solution to every personnel problem is to replace the manager. What matters for memory is that people are often products of their circumstances.

    This reframes the conversation from “how do I get more out of these people?” to “what is getting in the way of their success?“

    • Maybe the issue is unclear priorities. 
    • Perchance the real root problem is an unhealthy dependency on approvals. 
    • Perhaps your people have been rewarded for putting out fires, and are consequently avoiding the larger issues. 
    • Mayhaps conversations are consistently put off until after months of mounting tension. 
    • Possibly you’re not delegating enough and are always solving problems for people who need to learn how to handle them on their own. 

    These are the sorts of things good management can address: removing roadblocks and creating conditions for success.

    The most effective managers aren’t the ones who provide the most resources or information, but the ones who create an environment where their people feel empowered and supported. They promote autonomy, mastery, a sense of purpose, and belonging.

    To the untrained eye, the result may often look like the manager isn’t doing much of anything at all. When done well, management is a gruelingly difficult job that is completely invisible, because their role is to ensure everyone else’s role runs smoothly. When done correctly, management creates the conditions for performance rather than extracting performance through brute force of will.

    Often the most important questions aren’t about who is to blame for poor performance, but about who is most responsible for improvement. That doesn’t always make it the manager’s fault, but it does mean there’s always a right answer.

    Why Great Employees Don’t Stop Working Hard – They Stop Believing It Matters

    FacebooktwitterlinkedinFacebooktwitterlinkedin

    Why Great Employees Don't Stop Working Hard - They Stop Believing It Matters
    Motivation Is More Fragile Than We Think 

    For decades, companies have been trying to find a way to get employees to be more motivated.

    Some have tried to raise salaries, others have tried bonuses, employee-of-the-month plaques, team-building exercises, pizza Fridays, wellness programs, flexible schedules, or free coffee in the office (and the coffee is the cheapest one imaginable). 

    Every few years, a new management theory comes along, promising to revolutionize the workplace and unlock the secrets to engaged employees. Despite all this, it seems disengagement is still the norm and burnout is rampant. People are leaving well-paying jobs for seemingly little reason, while at the same time, refusing to budge from lower-paying ones.

    What gives? What does it all mean?

    The popular answer is simple: money is the most important motivator.

    On paper, it makes intuitive sense. People need money to survive, and more money usually means more luxuries. Seems logical, seems good. The problem is it’s only half true! 

    Money is an important motivator, surely, but it’s a motivator for getting a job, not for doing a good job. This is an outstanding distinction, because most companies don’t have trouble finding people willing to do the work. Getting people through the door is the easy part.

    Finding people willing to go above and beyond, solve problems, hone their skills, help out their coworkers, and really care about the job – now there…THERE’s your real challenge. Those things can’t be bought, and no, the old adage of “everyone has their price” doesn’t actually work.

    You’ll soon find out that as you increase the salary to keep up the good work & dedication, it goes up and up and up, becoming unsustainable. Then, sensing a shiver down your spine and a feeling of dread, you will quickly realize it was never about the money…but now you’re in the red.

    Money Isn’t the Villain, and It Never Was

    Before diving into the subject matter, it is important to dispel a common misconception that often surrounds discussions of motivation. In many cases, articles on the topic present the premise as a choice between paying employees well and providing them with motivation at work.

    In some cases, they go so far as to list “ways to motivate employees without spending money.” This is not an accurate perspective, however, as fair compensation is a necessity, and not a variable that should be bargained with.

    • If someone has to pay rent, cover utilities, feed their children, and buy groceries, motivation is most definitely not a priority.
    • If people are aware that they are significantly underpaid in comparison to their peers, motivation is not a priority.
    • If salaries barely see an increase from year to year, while workloads and expectations remain steady, motivation is not a priority.

    In all of these cases, money is the determining factor in an employee’s attitude and performance. It is an obvious point, but one that is often overlooked by management in favour of other, less effective, motivators.

    Money may not solve every problem, but it certainly helps in many cases. Few other motivators hold as much power when it comes to financial concerns. Therefore, it is plain to understand that fair pay is the foundation upon which motivation is built, rather than the other way around.

    Or, to put it in less academic terms: you cannot simply replace a raise with a pizza party.

    The Difference Between Showing Up and Caring

    One reason this myth was born is that compensation really does change behaviours.

    Pay someone more, and they will be more inclined to join your company. Offer someone a substantial bonus, and they will be motivated to perform better so that they can receive it. This is known as extrinsic motivation, and it works. Extrinsic motivation is real, and it is important. Without it, few individuals would willingly commit to forty hours of unpaid work each week. 

    However, once a person’s most basic needs are met, additional increases in compensation motivate them less and less. That’s where intrinsic motivation comes into play. 

    Think about it:

    • Why is it that some people always seem to seek out better ways of doing their jobs while others are quite happy to do the tasks that are simply required of them? 
    • Why do some teams manage to stay enthusiastic about their work while others burn out at the same salary? 
    • Why do some talented individuals choose to stay in their current position at a lower wage rather than move to a new company? 
    • Why do some employees remain deeply committed to an organization despite receiving offers with higher salaries elsewhere?
    • Why do people willingly go above and beyond for one manager, yet do only the bare minimum for another?

    This is the motivation that comes from within. Once people stop thinking about how money affects them, they start to think about how their work affects them. 

    People will rarely change their behaviours for a different paycheck if they feel that there is no impact beyond whether or not they can afford the food on the table and a roof over their head. 

    If they do not feel that their work has meaning, that they are contributing to something bigger than themselves, that they matter, then they are unlikely to put in extra effort.

    Motivation Is Not a Transaction

    Perhaps the easiest mistake to make when it comes to motivating employees is thinking it can be bought. It can’t.

    Companies often act as if motivation is something they can hand out like another type of compensation: raises, bonuses, employee recognition, wellness programs, benefits packages.

    Now, to be clear, all of these are important, but none of them are motivation. Motivation comes from somewhere else. It comes from the relationship between what employees put in and what they feel they get out: trust, opportunity, recognition, respect, growth, autonomy, fairness, meaning.

    It all adds up when you think about it. When employees feel as if they are no longer getting what they believe they deserve in return for their efforts, it doesn’t just affect their opinions of the company. It has a direct impact on their willingness to put in that effort in the first place.

    It happens gradually, almost imperceptibly at first.

    • People stop trying to contribute.
      • They stop experimenting.
        • They stop advocating for their ideas.
          • They stop caring.

    None of these things occur because they’ve decided the work itself isn’t worth it, but because they no longer feel it is.

    That, in the end, is the real reason for any drop in performance: not a change in the work itself, nor a shift in the challenges they face, but a feeling that the effort it takes for the rewards isn’t worth it.

    A far easier way to think of it is that people rarely stop working because they’re doing something hard. They stop working because they’ve decided the rewards for getting it done aren’t worth it.

    What Actually Keeps People Motivated?

    If fair payment is the basis, what else is missing?

    This is a question many psychologists and economists have asked for decades. Their main focus has been on finding the correlation between motivation and pay. The different perspectives have led to different conclusions. However, almost every theory boils down to one main idea, which, funnily enough, is also true for almost every aspect of human life:

    People will only stay motivated if their work continues to satisfy certain criteria.

    One of the theories, which has some strong points, is the Self-Determination Theory, or SDT for short. It focuses a lot on the quality of motivation. 

    Edward Deci and Richard Ryan, the psychologists who came up with it, believe that researchers should not think about motivation being high or low. Instead, the emphasis should be on the type of motivation a person is showing.

    Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation Aren’t Opposites

    Most people have heard of the concepts of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation.

    To keep matters brief, the former refers to one’s inner drive to engage in an activity, whereas the latter is one’s desire to engage in an activity to gain some reward from outside.

    While the ideas behind this division are not wrong, they are often misinterpreted since those who promote this view suggest that intrinsic motivation is good and that one should only strive for it. In contrast, extrinsic motivation is presented as bad, and one should even go so far as to actively shun it. 

    In reality, the truth, like people, is more nuanced and multifaceted. Few people are driven purely by one factor alone, and their motivational factors are usually intertwined and cannot be easily decoupled.

    • If one wants to become a competent software developer, one has to study and learn the subject matter regardless of any rewards that society offers. However, most developers choose this career solely because of rewards and benefits, such as high pay, opportunities to work remotely, and job stability.
    • Similarly, few nurses engage in their work purely for personal satisfaction, and most are motivated by the desire to help others, coupled with the ability to earn a comfortable income.
    • While some salespeople might love what they do and find fulfillment in building relationships with clients, most aim for career growth and the additional income that comes with it.
    • Likewise, many teachers enter the profession because they genuinely enjoy educating others and making a difference in young people’s lives, but they also expect stable employment, career progression, and compensation that reflects the importance of their work. 

    From an employer’s perspective, the best course of action is to make sure that their employees’ extrinsic motivations are well taken care of so that their work does not become a chore and they can continue bringing their best performance on the job.

    Autonomy Creates Ownership

    One of the most effective ways to predict long-term motivation is surprisingly simple: people want some level of control over how they work.

    Autonomy does not mean having no accountability or being completely independent in all aspects of work, but rather, having enough freedom from a controlling force to feel trusted in making decisions without being dictated at every step.

    Think about the difference between two contrasting office environments.

    1. A well-oiled machine; everyone knows their place, what is expected of them, and how to do it.
    2. A loosey-goosy environment, with laid-back guidelines, but more trust & confidence in their employees to figure out how to get the work done, even in a crisis.

    Both have equally competent workers, but which one do you think has the potential to create truly motivated employees?

    Well, let’s answer this question by saying ownership breeds motivation. People who have a sense of ownership in their work are more likely to think beyond what is asked of them and how they can make a difference. They see a problem before it is brought to them and take initiative in fixing it. They think beyond their job title and do the work because they want to, not because they are told to.

    As can be seen, this has absolutely nothing to do with accountability or lack thereof, but rather the feeling that they have a personal investment in what they do.

    Trust fosters a sense of ownership, and that leads to motivation, or in a more modern-worded take: people want to feel that they have a say in how they do their work.

    Mastery Makes Improvement Rewarding

    Think of any skill that you’ve learned over the past weeks, months, or years: driving, cooking, programming, writing, teaching, or playing an instrument.

    At first, you were most likely, probably not very good. You must have made lots of mistakes, and the work was hard, but THEN…then something magical happened. You started to get better. Things that were once hard became easy, and problems that seemed impossible became doable.

    This stoked a warm feeling deep inside, and your brain got hit by wave after wave of dopamine as you neared the solution to your challenges. The feeling only got greater as you saw yourself improving. Psychologists call this urge to improve mastery.

    Many companies fail to realize how important mastery is. Most people don’t just want a job. Some do, but eventually, after many dreary eves pass, even such individuals crave more.

    • They want a career
    • They want to learn and grow
    • They want to be challenged
    • They want to become experts in their field
    • They want to get better every day

    If you stop challenging your employees, you’ll start to see a drop in curiosity. They’ll still be putting in the hours, but they’ll feel like they aren’t really accomplishing anything, and your ambitious employees will get hit much harder by this than the average staff member. 

    That’s why companies that invest in making sure their employees are constantly learning and improving usually see much more than just an increase in technical skills. They send a message to their employees that they care about their future.

    In other words, employees are much more likely to stick around if they feel like they’re constantly improving.

    Purpose Gives Effort a Reason

    There is this phrase that most people never actually get to experience and is uttered in almost every mission statement: “Our people are our greatest asset!” 

    (If good taste would allow it, they’d add 3 !!!, and then the next company would do 4, and soon it would turn into an !-measuring contest)

    Purpose, as a concept, has followed suit much in the same way, sadly. It has become one of those hollow words that is overused in the corporate world, to the point it has become a meme.

    It is lamentable because a sense of purpose is one of those things that can be incredibly motivating for people. Purpose doesn’t necessarily mean that you’re doing something that will change the world. It just means that you know why you’re doing what you do.

    • A customer service rep who helps angry customers return products
    • An engineer who makes the widgets that people use every day
    • An accountant who keeps the company’s finances in order 
    • A janitor who ensures that the hospital is a clean environment for its patients
    • An IT technician who keeps the systems running so hundreds of colleagues can do their jobs without interruption
    • A warehouse worker who ensures that products reach customers accurately and on time

    They might not all be earth-shattering jobs, but they all have value, a sense of purpose, meaning, and impact on the world. What’s important is to realize that the thing they’re doing isn’t just something that they do for the sake of it. It needs to be something that they do for a reason, a purpose – that’s when it becomes transactional: do this for me, and I’ll give you that.

    It’s not a bad system, and there’s nothing wrong with it. For some people, that’s all they need. For many people, though, eventually, it becomes dissatisfying. They stop caring about doing the thing and start caring about why they should do the thing. That’s when the “I just want more money” becomes a problem. That’s also when people stop thinking about the task at hand and start thinking about why they should even care about it.

    It’s much harder to answer that question with a raise because money can’t achieve that. It can’t tell you why you should care about what you do. It can give you a reason to do it, but not a reason to care.

    Money talks to your wallet. Purpose talks to your soul.

    The Hidden Motivators Organizations Overlook

    By now, you should already know that motivation is not produced by a single source. It is generated through a multitude of interactions, and it can be created or destroyed by hundreds of tiny occurrences. Pay and perks matter, as does autonomy, professional development, and purpose.

    However, there are additional factors that have a significant impact on an employee’s motivation and engagement in the workplace in the long run. The crucial point is that these factors are rarely mentioned during job interviews: they are usually discussed in exit interviews.

    Fairness Builds Trust

    Imagine two similar employees: same salary, similar-ish work, equivalent ratings. Yet, out of the two, one always seems to get the plum assignments, public praise, endless cheer, and opportunities for promotion. 

    Now, the question at hand becomes: how long until the other begins to ask pungent, uncomfortable questions? Not long, I’d wager.

    This is due to the fact that one factor stands out as an extremely powerful motivator: the perception of fairness.

    Fairness in the workplace goes far beyond pay, as important as that is. It is the great equalizer, and it also entails consistency in how decisions are reached for things such as promotions, assignments, workload, kudos, mistakes, and communication.

    People may be willing to accept outcomes they do not like, but they are much less tolerant of confusing circumstances. When it comes to explaining a decision, transparency seems to have an enormous impact on whether people will accept it. Give people enough information that they can understand a choice, even if they are not happy about it, and they will be much more likely to accept it than if they are in the dark and suspect something negative might be lurking.

    When employees begin to feel as if they are getting less than they deserve, it is rarely productive to argue the point directly. Compensation issues, for example, are often emotional affairs, in which employees are apt to ask themselves not only how much they are being paid, but whether they are being treated fairly. By that, they often mean, how does my employer feel about my contributions?

    Compensation is one of those tell-tale signals of how much value a company feels like it is getting out of its employees. The company is constantly sending out signals via compensation levels, and the truth is often hard to disguise, even when no one is discussing it openly.

    Recognition Validates Contribution

    Recognition is one of the most misunderstood concepts in modern management.

    Many companies have turned it into a token, almost-jokey gesture: a monthly award, a thank-you note, an article in the company newsletter, a gift card.

    While all these things may have their value, they fail to address the most important aspect of recognition: the simple fact that people care whether what they do matters. Recognition is valuable because it reassures employees that their work has not been in vain.

    It is a response to the question “did what I do actually make a difference?” which is especially important when talking about demanding, difficult jobs. 

    “If I put my heart and soul into a challenging task and, when it finishes, nothing is said about it, does it mean it was not worth doing? Maybe it does not matter to me, but most likely, it will affect my motivation to do similarly demanding work in the future.”

    Recognition is valuable because it reassures employees that someone has noticed and that what they do matters to somebody. It should be noted, however, that recognition, in many ways, is a tool that can only be used effectively in a good workplace.

    If the company culture is unhealthy, and employees feel like their work is not valued, recognition gestures will do little to reassure them. They will see them as hollow tokens, attempts to manipulate them.

    Recognition cannot fix rotten foundations. It cannot compensate for constant underpayment or lack of appreciation. It should not be used in bad faith, as a way to cover up management’s mistakes.

    In simple, clear terms: pizza parties don’t fix broken workplaces.

    Progress Is One of Motivation’s Strongest Fuels

    Think about the last time you went all out trying really hard on some project. Now imagine there are two possible outcomes:

    • You see results. Things are coming together. You are improving. Things are getting done.
    • Despite your best efforts, things seem to get nowhere. One week seems much like the next. Problems arise, often in the same places. Goals appear ever distant, and your efforts seem to vanish up the memory hole, never to be remembered again.

    Which would make you feel better? Which would make you want to keep working? How do we feel when we are reminded that too many workplaces are inadvertently creating the second situation for their employees?

    Too many of us are working without the benefit of seeing the value of our efforts. Studies on worker motivation have shown that a sense of making progress is one of the most important factors in influencing positive emotional reactions toward work. That doesn’t mean we should expect huge leaps forward or giant achievements. 

    It means that people need to see some form of forward movement to feel good about what they do. It could be small steps. It could be baby steps, but people need reassurance that they’re actually getting somewhere. Some progress makes people feel their work has value. Without it, everything seems pointless.

    That’s why effective leaders acknowledge and celebrate progress all the time, not just when people reach the end goal. It’s not that people don’t need goals or don’t care about rewards, but because forward movement answers the silent question, “Are we really getting somewhere?“

    As long as the answer is “Yes,” then people can remain motivated. When the answer starts to sound more like “I’m not sure,” then well…that can be demotivating.

    People don’t need to finish the race each and every week. They just need to know they are still running towards the finish line.

    Burnout Isn’t a Motivation Problem

    Burnout is often attributed to something that happens when employees “just lose their motivation.” That’s a reductive view of what it means to experience burnout. It isn’t that sudden; it usually results from a slow process of exertion with decreasing perceived psychological return. 

    The workload increases, or the rewards for said work decrease, and the worker’s relationship with their work deteriorates. People begin to feel ineffective, powerless, unable to accomplish the things they think are important, even if their work itself doesn’t change. 

    People who suffer from burnout continue to perform their tasks because they feel like they have to, not because they feel like it has meaning or value. Most people can handle hard projects, long working hours during important periods, unexpected problems, and high levels of responsibility. What they can’t handle is feeling like all of their hard work is wasted, stagnant, irrelevant, or unnoticed. 

    When companies have people who are burned out, the default question is rarely “how can we incentivize these people to perform better?” but rather “what made them feel so devalued in the first place?” These are two completely different lines of inquiry with very different solutions. 

    Final Thoughts

    This article started with a simple myth: money is the greatest motivator.

    Like many myths, this one has a grain of truth. Money does matter – it satisfies basic needs, reduces stress, attracts people to the organization, and indicates whether the company cares about its employees. In other words, ignoring the importance of money would be foolish.

    However, it is only one factor influencing workers’ motivation. A more critical source of motivation is an individual’s perception of their work and how they are treated within the workplace. 

    Employees are more likely to be motivated if they realize their efforts make a difference, they improve themselves, their performance is valued, they can rely on their colleagues, and they are not stuck doing the same tasks. Such motivation is fragile, as it takes care to create the aforementioned circumstances.

    Many people think of motivation as a binary indicator: either individuals are motivated to work, or they are not. In reality, motivation is more of a continuum. This is why people need to feel their contributions are worthwhile, and they can rely on their colleagues. Organizations should focus more on nurturing a culture in which employees understand that their work matters. It will enable them to achieve greater productivity as motivated individuals will be more likely to go above and beyond.

    In today’s exceptionally modern times, there is no reason organizations shouldn’t strive to make employees feel that both money and non-monetary aspects of work are adequate. After all, people are unlikely to quit doing their tasks because they do not enjoy them. They are more likely to leave if they perceive no value in their efforts. People only experience dissatisfaction when their efforts do not provide them with rewards they want. Therefore, an organization should ensure that employees feel rewarded both intrinsically and extrinsically.

    *********

    Motivation is more complex than a paycheck. Build the knowledge and skills to manage employee performance with a broader understanding of what drives people at work through Certified Employee Performance Management

    How Sharpening Standards Set the Game-Winning Plan for Employee Management

    FacebooktwitterlinkedinFacebooktwitterlinkedin

    In the game of basketball, a well-defined playbook sets the foundation for a winning team. The same principle applies to nurturing a workplace culture. Without a strong framework, workplace culture can feel like a chaotic, uncoordinated game. According to Eric Lynn, Senior Learning Manager at Microsoft, establishing clear standards creates an environment where employees understand expectations, perform at their best, and contribute to a culture of excellence. He is also a professional coach at Microsoft’s Customer and Partner Solutions (MCAPS) organization, where his role is integral to supporting the company’s Growth Mindset Culture.

    Eric’s background in sports administration instilled in him a deep understanding of teamwork, strategy, and leadership, which he further refined through a Master of Science in Organizational Management and Leadership. With over 17 years of experience in learning and development, he shares in this interview a unique perspective on how training programs, strong leadership, and a results-driven approach can drive long-term business success. 

    From your own professional experience, what key elements are indispensable in cultivating a performance-oriented culture, and how have they influenced your work? 

    I think in a performance-based culture, it is imperative to have transparency and clear standards. If you can understand what the guidelines are and how to achieve them, the more consistent and impactful the team’s performance will be. 

    Strategic priorities today are being shaped by trends such as the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), reskilling efforts, and economic pressures, as highlighted in the World Economic Forum’s Future of Jobs 2025 report. In light of these trends, should we anticipate shifts in organizational culture? And if so, what might those changes look like? 

    Yes, and I believe we will be moving to a more team-oriented performance culture. Two reasons why a strong team culture is important in today’s workforce are that it helps improve our use of new technologies and enables us to work together to handle pressures, both economic and industry-based. While we tend to focus on individual performance, the leader of a work group or a senior-level employee will also be held accountable if they don’t have clear standards. When the rules are inconsistent, employees will be unable to make the impact needed to overcome the potential cuts brought about by the cultural shift. 

    In light of ongoing workplace shifts, which cultural trends do you think are having the greatest impact on increasing work productivity and individual performance? 

    The use of AI as a true partner for an individual will be a big transition for productivity and performance. I see that being able to work alongside this technology opens up and improves productivity. From a performance standard, it really allows individuals to focus on more important and pressing work. 

    In today’s agile work environment, sustainability continues to be a key strategic consideration. In your view, how can organizations truly embed sustainability values in their culture, beyond just meeting regulatory compliance? 

    I feel that diversity plays a significant role in how company members see and support each other. The more they embrace different perspectives and collaborate effectively, the stronger their ability to work together toward shared goals. In our organization, we avoid unnecessary travel and wasted time associated with in-person training events. Travel for a global workforce can not only create financial instability but also increase emissions and generate additional waste, such as food waste. It is important to balance return on investment with time spent to ensure we are acting as responsible global and financial stewards of the business.

    As organizations adapt to these cultural and strategic changes, what key actions can leaders take to make sure performance isn’t just maintained but enhanced? 

    Leaders need to be very clear on what the standards are for the team and organization. While there shouldn’t be a big departure between these, it is so important in a world riddled with changes that there is always a foundation on what the goal is for the team and organization. Leaders also need to foster a mindset wherein everyone counts; if a member of the team is struggling, we need to think about why and what can be done to help. It may be solved through training or having a conversation at the individual level, but I feel more and more that we need to have honest conversations around role changes and work scope. 

    A major factor influencing workplace culture and performance is work structure. How do you see changes such as the back-to-office push influencing employee motivation and effectiveness? In your opinion, is a remote or office-based approach better? 

    I find that if standards are clear and individuals are given autonomy, their workplace won’t matter— they will strive for success and contribute regardless.  However, I do feel that a lack of trust can be a significant factor affecting employees. Personally, I find a hybrid situation impactful and beneficial in managing expectations and more. 

    Given these structural and cultural shifts, what methods have you observed that organizations use to assess employee performance nowadays, and do these methods really help people achieve better results? 

    Organizations with a true team culture deliver the best team performance. When a company has subjective standards, it can be hard to take things seriously. Overall, I feel that the technology industry is taking a strong approach to accountability. I do like this approach, but in order for it to truly be effective and impactful, leaders must have a strong team culture with clear standards. 

    How can organizations make a smooth transition from the traditional rating and ranking evaluation system to agile employee performance management? 

    Having clear standards and providing solid coaching can uphold teams and employees. It is important that leaders remain curious and always review the process and the structure before jumping to the individual. I think organizations that do that and help those around them and see how they contribute can create a good environment centered around healthy performance management. 

    Looking at what works in practice, what is one tool, method, or approach that has proven most effective in your organization for driving employee performance?

    The principles around curiosity and coaching have been good at helping to remove judgment and inspection. One example involved a manager who had an opportunity to improve performance. Rather than inspecting or placing blame on the organization, we focused on key learnings that could guide future improvements and help carry the work forward. This approach demonstrates a vested interest in continuous improvement and in building examples of how this can work in the future.

    Asking thoughtful questions such as “What about…?” or “That’s a great idea—have we considered…?” helps to better understand the mindset behind decisions and fosters a more constructive approach to problem-solving.

    While performance incentives like targets and bonus systems are designed to drive results, they can sometimes lead to undesirable attitudes and consequences. How can organizations avoid the negative impacts of target setting at the employee level? 

    It has to come down to a strong correlation beyond the reward. Employees need to understand that it is about leaving an impact that helps improve a group versus not. While employees can receive a bonus for their performance, it really comes down to how the organization and the company feel. 

    Over the years, what’s been the most surprising or counterintuitive lesson you’ve learned about organizational culture, and how has it shaped your approach to leadership? 

    I have learned the importance of transparency, which means having clear standards of what excellence looks like in top performance. I have seen this effectively used by senior leaders by being very clear on expectations, allowing their teams to align with those standards. For example, this includes guidance on how to influence for impact, the key competencies required at each level, and the structural framework needed to make it work. I think of it like a motion offense in basketball—the more structure you give your players, the more ability and autonomy you give them to make the decisions.

    **********

    Editor’s Note: This article was originally published in Performance Magazine Issue No. 32, 2025 – Employee Performance Edition.

    THE KPI INSTITUTE

    The KPI Institute’s 2026 Agenda is now available! |  The latest updates from The KPI Institute |  Thriving testimonials from our clients |