Get the opportunity to grow your influence by giving your products or services prime exposure with Performance Magazine.

If you are interested in advertising with Performance Magazine, leave your address below.

    Advertise with us

    Education and Learning

    Performance Management for learning


    The following is an exerpt from a conference paper presented by Aurel Brudan at the 2009 Performance Measurement
    Association Conference in Dunedin, New Zealand. An edited version of the paper was published in the Measuring Business Excellence
    Journal in 2010 (vol. 14, No. 1), under the title:
    “Rediscovering performance management: Systems, learning and integration”

    From performance management for control to performance management for learning

    Traditionally, organisational performance management has been concerned with control, by setting and monitoring achievement of
    targets at strategic, operational and individual levels. Measurement has its benefits as it provides valuable information and
    measuring in itself stimulates higher performance.

    The Hawthorn effect and the Westinghouse effect or “Observer’s paradox” (Cukor-Avila, 2000) demonstrate the delicate nature of the
    measuring process and the impact that measurement itself has on the results.

    At strategic level, senior management supported by management accountants and finance professionals focus their efforts in
    translating organisational objectives in quantifiable targets. These objectives and targets are delegated to functional areas for
    implementation. Compliance with set targets is checked on a regular basis. These strategic objectives are then aligned with operational
    objectives and individual performance objectives. However, empirical evidence shows that the focus on the measurement and control in the
    context of performance management has started to diminish in the 1990s, driven by the increase in popularity of the BSC,
    Knowledge Management and Systems Thinking. Even the BSC was first presented in 1992 as a measurement tool promoted by the
    management accounting school and having roots in the quality movement. However it evolved quickly to become a complete management
    system supporting strategy implementation as a core competency. As a performance management tool, the BSC enables not only measurement
    and control, but also communication and learning.

    This shift is supported by proponents of the knowledge management/intellectual capital school of thought who argue that
    “the main problem with all measurement systems is that it is not possible to measure social phenomena with anything close to
    scientific accuracy
    ” (Sveiby and Armstong, 2004). They invoke Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle to illustrate the inherent
    imprecision in measurement that exists even in “exact” sciences such as physics. The principle states that uncertainties, or imprecision,
    always turn up if one tries to measure the position and the momentum of a particle at the same time (Cassidy, 1993, 1998).
    Neils Bohr famously stated that “Accuracy and clarity of statement are mutually exclusive” (for further details see Pais, 1994).
    Measurement for rewards leaves room for interpretation in the process of setting targets and measuring results and quite
    often leads to abuse. Using targets for control and linking the achievement of these targets to individual performance has the
    risk of staff members manipulating the system to their benefit and the expense of other teams and even the entire organisation.

    The alternative proposed to measurement for control is measurement for learning, as illustrated by the table below:

    Characteristic Measurement
    for control
    Measurement
    for learning
    Measurement
    drivers

    Management

    Employees

    Measures
    development

    Top-down
    commands

    Process-oriented
    bottom-up approach

    Measurement
    role

    Measuring
    and managing work in functional activities.

    Measuring
    and managing the flow of work thought the system

    Measurement
    focus

    Productivity
    output, targets, standards: related to budget

    Capability,
    variation: related to purpose

    Results
    communication

    Restricted

    Open

    Target
    driven by

    Budget/political
    aspirations

    Understanding
    achievement versus purpose

    Follow-up
    to results

    Rewards,
    punishment and action to improve results

    Dialogue
    and improvement

    Learning
    cycle

    Single
    loop

    Double
    loop learning

    Link
    to rewards

    Link
    to individual rewards and recognition system

    Group
    rewards, based on improvement

     

    Table: Measurement for control compared to measurement for learning, Brudan, 2010

    Thus the Systems Thinking approach to performance management, coupled with the emphasis on learning, highlight the need for an integrated approach to performance management. Effective performance management requires more than measuring and reporting in isolation.

    References

    • Brudan A.N. (2010), “Rediscovering performance management: systems, learning and integration”, Measuring Business Excellence, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 109-123.
    • Cassidy, D. (1993), “Uncertainty: The Life and Science of Werner Heisenberg”, W. H. Freeman, New York, pp. 226-246.
    • Cassidy, D. C. (1998), “Answer to the Question: When Did the Indeterminacy Principle Become the Uncertainty Principle?” American Journal of Physics, Nr. 66, pp. 278-279
    • Cukor-Avila, P. (2000) “Revisiting the Observer’s Paradox”, American Speech, Vol.75, Nr. 3 pp. 253-254.
    • Pais, A. (1994), “Niels Bohr’s Times: In Physics, Philosophy, and Polity”, Oxford University Press, Oxford, England pp. 304-309.
    • Sveiby, K. E. and Armstrong C.(2004). “Learn to Measure to Learn!”, opening keynote address at the Intellectual Capital Congress Helsinki, 2 Sept 2004.

    THE KPI INSTITUTE

    The KPI Institute’s 2026 Agenda is now available! |  The latest updates from The KPI Institute |  Thriving testimonials from our clients |